While criticizing challenger Senator John Kerry for
"waffling," President George W. Bush has
been a model of consistencyin a peculiar manner
of speaking: Time after time, he and members of
his administration have said one thing, and then
acted directly to the contrary. "What's so
strange about that?" you may ask. "After
all, he's a politician. Ha, ha!"
What's strange is that this is the comic stereotype,
to which no real person in living memory has actually
conformed more than slightly. Practically any
politician you can name has actually carried through
on some, perhaps as many as half, of his or her
promises.
But not G.W.Bush. If we examine his record,
we find that the number of times he has deviated from
the absurd stereotype is astonishingly low.
This pattern of say-one-thing-and-do-another has been
so consistent that duplicity has become the de
facto watchword of his administration.
Time and again, Bush and his colleagues have sung the
praises of various groups, programs, and ideals, and
then systematically undercut those groups,
underfunded those programs, and undermined those
ideals. Though there have been occasional
exceptions, it is difficult to think of instances
where Bush's policy of saying one thing and doing
another has not been faithfully (if unscrupulously)
applied. Indeed, by now the pattern is so
familiar and predictable that praise from this
president is becoming regarded by many as something
akin to a kiss of death.
I admit this might appear to be a joke. It
sounds far fetched. The title seems comical,
the claims exaggerated, and the commentary wry.
No doubt, some readers are convinced I'm either
kidding or crazy. But let's consider some
examples, and then see whether anyone is still
laughing.
THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION RECORD
A Review of the
Texas Chainsaw Presidency |
WHAT THEY'VE SAID |
WHAT THEY'VE DONE |
AFGHANISTAN:
Following the 9/11 disaster, President Bush vowed
to hunt down terrorists worldwide and bring them
to justice. |
In a rare
instance of actually fulfilling a public promise,
the Bush administration sent troops to
Afghanistan, which had been dominated by the
brutally fanatical Taliban regime. Cooperative
efforts between U.S. and Pakistani forces
effectively drove out terrorist training
operations from all but a few remote areas, and
restored control of Afghanistan to the native
population. |
CHILDREN'S
HEALTH: Bush has publicly praised health
care and hospitals for children. |
Bush has tried
to freeze grants for children's hospitals. He has
proposed a $94 million cut in the Community
Access program, which provides funding to
hospitals in need. He is also trying to cut $158
million (68%) in training grants for specialties,
including pediatrics. Meanwhile, his budget
provides billions for the health insurers that
have been among his major contributors. |
CORE
CONSTITUENCY: At a fundraising dinner
limited to the very wealthy, Mr. Bush addressed
those present as "a gathering of the haves
and the have-mores." He continued,
"Some call you the elite. I call you my
base." |
Though
intended to amuse his restricted audience, Bush'e
remark was uncharacteristically accurate,
unabashedly reflecting greed as the supreme value
of his administration, to the exclusion of all
other concerns except as expedient and
convenient. |
DEFENSE:
Bush heaps praise upon America's military men and
women, and declares that they should be the best
trained and equipped in the world. |
While military
spending by the U.S. exceeds that of all other
nations combined, thousands of soldiers have been
sent to war in Iraq without proper equipment and
protection. Vehicles were inadequately armored
for an environment in which land mines and rocket
fire were to be expected. Initially soldiers even
lacked Kevlar body armor, unless their own
families bought it for them. |
DEFICIT:
Bush has attributed the federal
deficitwhich abruptly replaced the
projected surplus he inherited from the Clinton
administrationto a variety of causes: the
economic recession, the 9/11 attacks, the war in
Iraq, government spending. |
The
Congressional Budget Office reveals that
government spending now is "at a lower level
than any year from 1975 through 1996." It
also identifies the largest (36%) single
contributor to the deficit as the Bush tax cuts,
90% of which went to the wealthiest Americans. It
would seem, then, that this is the main reason
Team Bush has needed to cut funding for
everything else, from military armor to Medicare. |
EDUCATION:
Bush has promised substantial support for public
education. He touts his "No Child Left
Behind" program, which holds local schools
accountable for students' performance. |
The
requirement for improved performance is certainly
long overdue. However, the Bush budget typically
underfunds the NCLB program by about one third.
Without adequate funding, many local schools find
it impossible to comply with the law. Unable to
attract and retain qualified teachers, they're
forced to downsize or close, leaving hundreds of
thousands of childrenparticularly the
disadvantagedbehind. Then, adding insult
to injury, Education Secretary Paige has glibly
characterized school teachers as terrorists. (He
subsequently said he was only kidding, but this
administration's systemic disconnection between
rhetoric and reality gives us ample cause to
wonder.)
|
EMPLOYMENT:
Bush stresses the importance of jobs and the
virtues of the American worker. He has often made
photo-ops at industrial sites, talking and
shaking hands with workers. |
It's ironic
that some of the very factories where Bush has
staged his publicity bids have downsized or shut
down soon thereafter. Indeed, the Bush
administration has itself moved some of its own
publicity and fund-raising activities offshore,
declaring outsourcing as "good for
America.". But American workers whose jobs
have been outsourced are apt to disagree. Bush
eagerly credits his policies with the recent
creation of hundreds of thousands of jobs, though
most of these offer lower pay than the millions
previously lost. Attempting to shine the best
possible light on the figures, he has proposed
reclassifying fast-food preparation as a
"manufacturing" job. Yet no matter how
he juggles it, G.W.Bush can't squirm away from
the fact that he is the first president since
Herbert Hoover to preside over a net job loss.
|
ENERGY:
President Bush affirms that he has put money and
research behind alternative energy projects such
as a hydrogen-fueled car. |
The potential
benefit of alternate energy-source technology is
reduction of dependence on non-renewable fossil
fuels. However, the specific technology in
question uses hydrogen converted from coal, oil,
and gas. The plans for it were developed by the
fossil fuel industries that have largely
bankrolled the Bush-Cheney team, and the funding
for it is siphoned off from programs that would
actually reduce fossil fuel use.. |
ENVIRONMENT:
On Earth Day in 2002, President Bush declared
"we should do more at the federal
level" to deal with air pollution. |
In 2004, the Wall
Street Journal reported a meeting between
the Bush administration and oil executives, to
consider weakening EPA standards for pollutants
in gasoline. |
FISCAL
RESPONSIBILITY: In promoting his tax
cuts, Bush promised that his administration's
budget would be balanced over the long term. |
Bush's
administration inherited from Clinton's the first
projected budgetary surplus in decades. But
within Bush's first year in officeeven
before the 9/11 disasterthe surplus was
being replaced by the largest projected deficit
ever. |
PERSONAL
INCOME: As employment finally began to
rise in 2004, Vice President Cheney remarked that
"real incomes and wages are growing." |
A recent study
by the Economic Policy Institute shows that,
while corporate profits and CEO compensation have
soared, real income for average workers has
actually fallen. Newly created jobs typically pay
21% less than those that have been lost.
Meanwhile, Bush is pushing to eliminate overtime
compensation for 8 million workers, and opposes
any increase in the minimum wage. |
PRISONERS
OF WAR: Bush distanced his
administration from the maltreatment of Iraqi
detainees at Abu Ghraib Prison, deploring those
abuses as "disgraceful conduct by a few
American troops who dishonored our country and
disregarded our values." |
A 2002 White
House directive characterizes the Geneva
Convention protections for POWs (including
Americans) as "quaint" and
"obsolete." Communications among the
President, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld, and
Attorney General Ashcroft reveal deliberate
intent to disregard this historic and humane
international agreement. Over objections of State
Secretary Powell and military lawyers, the
administration has endorsed a secret system of
detention and interrogation, in which humiliation
and torture of detainees and prisoners is not
only condoned, but actively encouraged by top
White House officials. Rather than addressing
the abusive policy, the Bush White House has
instead launched an assault against the soldiers
and journalists who exposed the wrongdoing,
claiming that such reporting "is undermining
support for the war."
|
SENIORS'
HEALTH: Bush has nothing but kind words
for America's elderly. He says they deserve
choices. |
Bush staunchly
opposes allowing seniors to purchase discounted
prescription drugs through Canadian suppliers.
Furthermore, his modifications to Medicare force
many seniors into HMOs, which enjoy generous
government subsidies. His budget cuts are
projected to drive Medicare into bankruptcy in a
decade or soabout when demand for medical
services by the "baby-boomer"
generation approaches its peak. For millions of
them, the choice will be between having food or
getting medical care. (So maybe you're not a
senior. Do you have parents who are?)
|
SEPTEMBER
11 RESCUE: Standing atop a rubble heap
at Ground Zero, President Bush lavishly praised
rescue workers at the WTC disaster scene in New
York. |
EPA press
releases, intended to warn the public of toxic
levels near Ground Zero, were altered by the
White House Council on Environmental Quality
(headed by James Connaughton, a former asbestos
industry lawyer) to say that the air there was
safe. When New York police and firefighters began
falling ill, the administration sought to cut off
health care screening and $90 million in health
care funding. Though Congress overrode this move,
New York is still struggling to find the means to
provide these heroic individuals the care they
deserve. Recently, 1,700 9/11 rescue workers have
had to sue for desperately needed medical
assistance. |
SPACE
EXPLORATION: Hoping to present a
forward-looking image, Bush has proposed that
NASA shift its emphasis toward mannned missions
to the moon and Mars. |
At this point,
manned interplanetary missions are not feasible.
The only manned space vehicles the U.S. has today
are the aging shuttles. The Apollo technology
that took Americans to the moon 35 years ago has
long since been dismantled, and the people who
designed and worked on it are no longer around. A
replacement would have to be virtually
reinvented. And a manned mission to Mars is just
a distant dream at this point. However, NASA
will indeed have to shift emphasis in one
important sense. Due in part to Bush's
funding cuts, it will have to shut down the
Hubble Space Telescope, whose astounding images
have over the past 14 years reshaped the human
vision of the universe.
|
SPECIAL
INTERESTS: Bush criticizes his political
opponents as "beholden to special interests
and out of touch with regular Americans." |
If political
contributions and favors are any indication, the
Bush team is beholden to a great many special
interests, including automakers, defense
contractors, HMOs, insurers, meat processors, oil
producers, and the pharmaceutical industry, to
name but a few. Evidently, these are the sort of
people Mr. Bush thinks of as "regular
Americans." |
TAX
CUTS: Initially, candidate Bush called
for tax cuts because the economy was doing so
well. Then President Bush called for tax cuts
because the economy was doing so poorly and
needed a boost. |
Bush cut
taxes, all right. But for the average worker,
investor, or small business operator, the cuts
add up to only a few hundred dollars. Elimination
of the top tax bracket diverted most of the tax
relief to those who need it leastlarge
corporations and millionaires, whose tax cuts
average out to nearly $90,000 apiece. This is
what Mr. Bush calls "fair." Fair or
not, this latest attempt at supply-side strategy
has been remarkable only in the duration of its
ineffectiveness. Because trickle-down does little
to stimulate broad consumer demand (without which
business has little incentive to increase
production and hiring), its real value as an
economic stimulus is minimal to non-existent.
To be fair, Bush can't be blamed for the onset
of cyclical economic contraction. But the economy
has languished, for far longer and at far greater
overall cost in debt, jobs, and capital, than
would likely have been the case with prudent and
timely targeting of resources. Now that the
economy is finally struggling to rebound in its
natural cycle, Bush is predictably eager to take
credit.
|
TAX
FAIRNESS: Bush has said he wants to
"make sure the system is fair for those of
us who do pay taxes," and that "we want
everybody paying their fair share." |
In 2002, when
Congress was attempting to close tax loopholes
for offshore businesses, Bush allies killed the
legislation. In June 2004, the Bush
administration awarded a $10 billion Homeland
Security contract to Accenture (formerly Andersen
Consulting), a company that had moved its
headquarters to Bermuda to avoid paying U.S.
taxes. In addition, Bush initiatives have
reduced IRS audits of corporations while
increasing audits of individuals.
|
VETERANS:
Bush praises the courage, loyalty, and sacrifices
of American military veterans, and proclaims that
the nation owes them an enormous debt. |
Bush has tried
to shut down veterans' hospitals across the
nation, and has decided to cut off prescription
drug benefits for 164,000 veterans. He has
threatened to veto any bill allowing veterans to
enjoy both pensions and medical benefits, and has
planned, if reelected, to cut veterans' health
care funding by $1 billion in 2005. |
WEAPONS
OF MASS DESTRUCTION: President Bush
cited intelligence reports of Iraq's possession
of WMD as justification for a preemptive strike.
When, after the war was in progress, it came to
light that the intelligence was very unreliable,
there was great pressure on the president to
establish an independent investigation. |
There is
troubling evidence that Bush had intended to
invade Iraq since even before September 2001.
Shaky though it was, the "intelligence"
of Iraq's alleged arsenal and dealings with al
Quaeda afforded him an excuse to proceed,
diverting precious resources from Afghanistan.
When the intelligence indeed turned out to be
bogus, critics called for an independent
investigation. Yielding to persistent pressure,
Bush finally complied. But, true to form, he
insisted upon choosing the investigating team
himselfcontrary to established practice,
and hardly a formula for an independent probe.
And, of course, he set a target date comfortably
after the November election. Bush's habit of
playing fast and loose with the truth has
squandered the good will of the world following
the 9/11 attacks. American credibility has been
eroded nearly to levels characteristic of China
and Iran, whose peculiar notions of truth are
traditionally defined more by policy than by
reality. Victims of Bush's web of confusion and
deceit include not only the men and women of the
American armed forces, but also the coalition
allies, whose leaders are now suffering the
domestic political consequences for having allied
themselves with an impulsive warmonger.
(Comment: It is the
misfortune of these allied leaders to be so
accused by their countrymen, when in fact the
grim specter of an unchecked superpower, led by a
man with no clear concept of reality and
apparently few scruples, has forced them into the
unpleasant role of damage control. While they
fully understand the threat that the Bush
"Axis of Evil" crusade poses to world
peace, they nevertheless realize that it is only
through their active involvement that there can
be any hope of mitigating that threat. Deluged by
public criticism, they daily struggle to keep
Bush from losing his focus on terrorism, tossing
diplomacy out the window, and turning the entire
Middle East into a war zone. Blair and the
others, of course, cannot defend their unpopular
stance by publicly discussing the situation's
full implications, for to do so would certainly
destroy what limited leverage their alliance
provides to restrain the Bush loose cannon. But
this American applauds these dedicated,
far-sighted, self-sacrificing statesmen, who
place the welfare of the world above their own
political futures. Would that we Yanks had the
wisdom to elect such leaders!)
|
Data are generated by numerous
governmental and journalistic sources, acquired and
released through The
Daily Mislead and
other channels, and distilled here for the reader's
convenience. While effort is made to present material
faithfully, no guarantee can be made against possible
errors.
Yes, George W. Bush is amazingly
consistent, in his curiously self-contradictory way.
By comparison, even "Tricky Dick" Nixon
could point with pride to some positive
accomplishments of his administration. We would have
to hark back to the combined administrations of
Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover to find an example of
consistent corruption, cronyism, and deterioration
equivalent to that exhibited in the single term of
G.W.Bush. In that brief span, the nation's economy
has been hobbled, its poor and middle classes
squeezed for the benefit of the wealthy, its children
and elderly victimized, its military misused for
dubious ends, its solemn agreements renounced at
whim, and its credibility worldwide reduced to the
level of those very "Axis of Evil" entities
it despises. Even the traditional friends and allies
now view the United States as out of control, a wild
and undisciplined entity no longer to be respected
and trusted, but only feared.
We could do well, in the opinion of
many, with a substantially smaller measure of that
sort of consistency. While we have no guarantee that
John Kerry would be any better, the law of averages
is strongly in his favor, for it is unthinkable that
he could do any worse.
=SAJ=
|